Old standby

Pretty good. Not ton of pumpkin flavor. Almost tastes like a Stout.

Delicious! Great pumpkin flavor. I've had better but only one

Fantastic all around pumpkin beer. In my top 2 for sure

Not terrible, just overall bland. Really no taste of pumpkin, and there's just this bland ambiguous blend of autumn spices, with no distinctive flavors. The general maltiness takes over, and you're left with a passable, but hardly notable, pumpkin ale.

Pretty clean pumpkin taste that doesn't have a lot of the accompanying pumpkin spices that other pumpkin beers have. Which means a pretty good drinkabilty but the price is a bit high for a pumpkin beer. Over all 3 stars

Really nice pumpkin flavor. Lots of pumpkin beer/ale has very little of a pumpkin taste, this one is the exception.

Smooth, not bitter but full flavor brown, good spices, not too strong

Liked the brown sugar addition, it was a little pricey compared to other pumpkins ale equal in price

A brown ale that isn't very brown. A pumpkin ale without much pumpkin. A simple ale that isn't very simple. A Dogfish Head beer that isn't outrageously over the top (which isn't very Dogfish Head). Decent, drinkable ale with the slight tastes of roasted pumpkin, allspice and nutmeg. It doesn't have that fake pumpkin pie flavoring that most pumpkin beers have.