Tastes bitter and acidic

I would never second-guess SS for their quality but I waver on this beer's need to exist. There is just nothing special here. Does nothing exceptional. Lacks focus. Others winter ales are far superior. Seek them out.

Crisp and spicy, though lighter than I expected, both in body and in colour. Certainly on the malty side, but considerably tasty. Not much nose, but spice notes hit the roof of your mouth and top of your tongue, and are noticeable in the finish. Wouldn't buy from a store, but wouldn't overlook it on tap once temperatures drop. Though I'd hesitate to call it a warmer, it fits perfectly to cold weather.

One of the best beers ever.

Dark and smooth.. Def a beer for BBQ or something grilled

Personal Note: This is nothing to write home about. I paid a clearance price for this beer and that was almost too much for what got. Best part was that I can use the bottle for my home brews. First Taste: Haskell's liquor store, Maple Grove MN Cost: Unknown, Clearance: $2.99; 20 oz'er

Enjoyed this beer!! Smooth had a wine like after taste which was pretty good. Sweet and malty.. Yum

Mt - Solid

It starts with an orange-brown body and white head. There's some spice in the nose with a little roasted malt character. It's smooth in the mouth with a dryness that's interesting. There is some subtle fruitiness when it first hits your tongue. A small pop of brightness. The finish is a little bitter and long. It's kinda hard to catergorise this beer. There are parts I enjoy - the pop of fruit, and the bitterness; but it's overall kind of a bland, boring beer. I expected more out of Samuel Smith. EDIT: The more I drink it, the more it grows on me. I think I would say it's a solid beer - a strong base with nothing remarkable on top of it. I revised my earlier score of 2.5 up to a 3.5.

Excellent beer for the cold days.